This week David presented the final encounter in this series from John’s gospel.
He began by asking: What is Truth?
Truth is important: it features in songs, books and films in our culture. But does it matter anymore? Has it become corroded or subjective?
During this encounter, recorded in John 18:28-19:16, Pontius Pilate asks Jesus this very question.
On the night Jesus was arrested and questioned by the Jewish authorities, they handed him over to Pilate, wishing to have him sentenced to death.
That night, Pilate asked at least seven questions. Those questions and Jesus’ answers have a great impact on our lives today.
1. “Are you the King of the Jews?”
Pilate had heard this claim; if true, it would be a problem. Anyone claiming to be a king would need to be dealt with. However, Jesus responds with a question:
“IS THAT YOUR OWN IDEA…OR DID OTHERS TALK TO YOU ABOUT ME?”
John 18:34
For Pilate and for us the answer must be personal. Who do you say Jesus is?
Pilate dismisses Jesus’ question and asks:
2. “What have you done?”
Jesus replies by speaking of his spiritual Kingdom:
“MY KINGDOM IS NOT OF THIS WORLD.”
John 18:36
Pilate can only think in earthly terms – worldly power, domination and prestige. Jesus’ Kingdom, however, operates with different values – humility, grace, love, trust, child-like faith and service.
Wanting an easy answer and a swift resolution, Pilate responds:
3. “So you are a king?”
Jesus acknowledges this, explaining:
“YOU SAY THAT I AM A KING. FOR THIS PURPOSE I WAS BORN AND FOR THIS PURPOSE I HAVE COME INTO THE WORLD – TO BEAR WITNESS TO THE TRUTH. EVERYONE WHO IS OF THE TRUTH LISTENS TO MY VOICE.’
John 18:37
Jesus was born to fulfil the prophecies about the Messiah and to be the King of Kings.
The mention of ‘truth’ causes Pilate to retort:
4. “What is Truth?”
Although Pilate does not give Jesus the chance to answer, the answer was standing in front of him. Jesus had previously said: “I am the Truth.” (John 14:6)
If we want to know what truth is today, we need to encounter Jesus, allowing him to change our whole life.
Pilate returns to the Jews, stating, “I find no fault in Him.” Jewish tradition permitted a prisoner to be released at Passover, however the crowd demand that a notorious criminal Barabbas be freed instead of Jesus.
Like Barabbas we are guilty – but Jesus died to take away our sins.
HE BORE OUR SINS IN HIS BODY ON THE TREE…BY HIS WOUNDS WE ARE HEALED.
1 Peter 2:24
Not wishing to execute Jesus, Pilate orders him to be scourged instead. But this does not pacify the crowd who cry “Crucify Him!” Why? ‘Because he claimed to be the ‘Son of God’ (John 19:7).
Alarmed at this Pilate asks Jesus:
5. “Where are you from?”
But Jesus gives him no answer.
Where do we believe Jesus is from? He said he had come from the Father (John 16:38).
Because of Jesus’ silence Pilate asks:
6. “Do you not know that I have authority to release you and authority to crucify you?”
Jesus responds:
“YOU WOULD HAVE NO AUTHORITY OVER ME AT ALL UNLESS IT HAD BEEN GIVEN YOU FROM ABOVE.”
John 19:11
Hearing Jesus’ answer, Pilate seeks to release him, but the crowd will not relent. Demanding crucifixion, they shout:
“IF YOU RELEASE THIS MAN, YOU ARE NOT CAESAR’S FRIEND.”
John 19:12
Fearful of this accusation, Pilate brings Jesus out, asking:
7. “Shall I crucify your king?”
The people answer yes. Pilate hands Jesus over – and his encounter with Jesus is over.
How did this encounter affect Pilate?
Other gospel accounts record Pilate’s wife warning him to have nothing to do with Jesus. Instead of releasing him, he publicly ‘washed his hands’ of Jesus’ blood. However, Pilate ordered a sign to be attached to Jesus’ cross:
JESUS OF NAZARETH, THE KING OF THE JEWS.
John 9:19
He resisted demands from the Jewish authorities for it to be changed.
Perhaps he began to come to some kind of recognition of who Jesus was?
Reflection
- What is ‘Truth’? The answer is Jesus.
Prayer
- May we encounter Jesus and discover who he really is.