Faith That Works 5

James had a passionate belief that our Christian faith and our works must coincide. Today’s passage – James 2:14-26 – hammers this home.

  • Challenge: Is there a gap between my faith and how I behave? If so, we are warned to ‘MIND THE GAP’!

“WHAT GOOD IS IT, MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS, IF SOMEONE CLAIMS TO HAVE FAITH BUT HAS NO DEEDS? CAN SUCH FAITH SAVE THEM?”

It’s easy to claim to be a Christian, but do our actions confirm our claim? James implies here that a mere profession of faith unsupported by good deeds is not saving faith. In these verses he sets out the marks of two kinds of faith: fake and genuine.

1. FAKE FAITH:
Example:

“SUPPOSE A BROTHER OR A SISTER IS WITHOUT CLOTHES AND DAILY FOOD. IF ONE OF YOU SAYS TO THEM, ‘GO IN PEACE; KEEP WARM AND WELL FED,’ BUT DOES NOTHING ABOUT THEIR PHYSICAL NEEDS, WHAT GOOD IS IT?”

Verdict:

“IN THE SAME WAY, FAITH BY ITSELF, IF IT IS NOT ACCOMPANIED BY ACTION, IS DEAD.”

Genuine Christians will respond to all in need, but especially to those within our Christian communities (see Galatians 6:10).

Objection:

“BUT SOMEONE WILL SAY, ‘YOU HAVE FAITH; I HAVE DEEDS.’”

Surely there are different types of faith and all are valid?

Response:

Genuine faith, James insists, will always be expressed in how we live, whereas fake faith is invisible.

2. GENUINE FAITH:
Example 1: Abraham (see Genesis ch.22)

“WAS NOT OUR FATHER ABRAHAM CONSIDERED RIGHTEOUS FOR WHAT HE DID WHEN HE OFFERED HIS SON ISAAC ON THE ALTAR?”

Example 2: Rahab (see Joshua ch.2)

IN THE SAME WAY, WAS NOT EVEN RAHAB THE PROSTITUTE CONSIDERED RIGHTEOUS FOR WHAT SHE DID WHEN SHE GAVE LODGING TO THE SPIES AND SENT THEM OFF IN A DIFFERENT DIRECTION?”

Verdict:

“YOU SEE THAT A PERSON IS CONSIDERED RIGHTEOUS BY WHAT THEY DO AND NOT BY FAITH ALONE.”

Both Abraham and Rahab (from very different backgrounds) are commended for demonstrating their faith through their actions.

Objection:

Isn’t there a contradiction between this teaching of James (verse 24) and the Apostle Paul’s emphasis on salvation through faith (see Ephesians 2:8-9)?

Response: Paul was speaking into a context where people were saying that in order to be really saved, you had to perform certain rituals/routines – works of the law – and he was challenging that perspective:

“FOR WE MAINTAIN THAT A PERSON IS JUSTIFIED BY FAITH APART FROM THE WORKS OF THE LAW.”

Paul states (Ephesians 2:8-9) that we are saved by faith alone; he follows up by saying:

“FOR WE ARE GOD’S HANDIWORK, CREATED IN CHRIST JESUS TO DO GOOD WORKS, WHICH GOD PREPARED IN ADVANCE FOR US TO DO.”

Paul makes it clear that we are saved by faith alone. James shows us that saving faith never remains alone. There is no contradiction!

Reflection:

  • When we hear God’s Word we must not stop there – action is required.
  • Faith that works is faith that works.
Picture of Dorothy McMillan

Dorothy McMillan

I’m Dorothy and I coordinate the Deep Dives part of the WBC website. I’ve been a member of WBC for around 30 years and have worked as a teacher, playgroup leader and college lecturer. Now that I have retired, I enjoy doing patchwork, reading and spending time with our four wonderful grandchildren.
Picture of Dorothy McMillan
I’m Dorothy and I coordinate the Deep Dives part of the WBC website. I’ve been a member of WBC for around 30 years and have worked as a teacher, playgroup leader and college lecturer. Now that I have retired, I enjoy doing patchwork, reading and spending time with our four wonderful grandchildren.