FIGHT CLUB: 3. Men and Women

Whilst today’s passage (1 Tim 2:8-15) is primarily about gathered worship, David cautioned that it also contains some of the most controversial verses in the New Testament, therefore, we should approach these carefully and prayerfully, with guarded hearts.

I DESIRE THEN THAT IN EVERY PLACE THE MEN SHOULD PRAY

Paul zeros in on the lives of men in the church with an impassioned desire that they should always pray in every situation.

To the men David asked, “Are you a praying man, Is prayer a regular feature in your life, where’s the evidence?”

LIFTING HOLY HANDS

To ‘lift holy hands’ was a typical Old Testament posture that represented a holy, clean and pure life before the Lord (Cf. Ps 28:2).

For all men, this is a divine command to ‘be holy as God is holy’, in all aspects of life, speech, actions, and thought.

David asked, “Are your hands clean – is holiness a pursuit and a characteristic of your entire life?”

WITHOUT ANGER OR QUARRELLING’

It is inappropriate to approach God in prayer when we are angry or have been quarrelling, without first reconciling our behaviour and seeking his forgiveness. (Cf. Matt 5:22-24, Mark 11:25).

LIKEWISE ALSO THAT WOMEN SHOULD ADORN THEMSELVES IN RESPECTABLE APPAREL, WITH MODESTY AND SELF-CONTROL,

Turning his attention towards women in the church, Paul focuses on appearance linked to gathered worship and public witness. His concern appears to be that women should not dress over extravagantly or inappropriately, but rather their clothing should be respectable, modest and with decency and propriety.


The question is, who determines when a line is crossed or what someone wears is indecent or inappropriate? I found a helpful little article on what it means to dress modestly on ‘Got Questions’ https://www.gotquestions.org/dress-modestly.html.

NOT WITH BRAIDED HAIR AND GOLD OR PEARLS OR COSTLY ATTIRE, BUT WITH GOOD DEEDS, APPROPRIATE FOR WOMEN WHO PROFESS TO WORSHIP GOD

Paul was likely alluding to the suggestive and seductive dress code of the many women who were involved in temple worship of the goddess Diana.

Whilst there remain some underlying principles for women in the church today regarding image and attire, Paul finishes out with the primary motive – prioritise inner beauty and character through devotion to God (Cf. 1 Pet 3:3-4).

THE CHURCH SHOULD BE A VERITABLE BEAUTY PARLOUR, BECAUSE IT ENCOURAGES ITS WOMEN MEMBERS TO ADORN THEMSELVES WITH GOOD DEEDS

In the lead-in to verses 11-15, David referred to a paper that WBC produced in 2006 which examined some key principles regarding the roles of men and women in the church. It outlined the two main positions of Complementarianism and Egalitarianism. He said that how each of us interprets these verses will be influenced by whichever position we hold regarding the role of women in the church.

I DO NOT PERMIT A WOMAN TO TEACH OR TO ASSUME AUTHORITY OVER A MAN

Paul underpins this teaching with a creation account ordinance which reinforces that men and women have different roles and confirms that the principle of male headship and authority is timeless and never cultural. However, others may interpret these verses within a specific first century cultural setting to infer that this principle doesn’t apply today.

In short, WBC’s position and practice is that authority and pastoral leadership in the church is the responsibility of male elders, and a woman may teach in this context.

YET SHE WILL BE SAVED THROUGH CHILDBEARING—IF THEY CONTINUE IN FAITH AND LOVE AND HOLINESS, WITH SELF CONTROL

David acknowledged that this is a notoriously difficult verse to understand but the most likely interpretation is that women will be saved through the birth of the Child, referring to Christ, who was born of Mary and without whom there would be no salvation for anyone (Cf. v.5, Gen 3:15).

Takeaways:

  • For men it’s the priority of prayer, the call to holiness and the need to get rid of anger and disputes
  • For women it’s the practice of good deeds and the importance of dress
  • For men and women, it’s the challenge to understand roles and functions within the church today
Picture of Patrick Davidson

Patrick Davidson

I’m Patrick and I oversee one of the small groups at Windsor. I work in a sixth form centre, and volunteer with CAP and The Dock café. Prior to this I worked as a project manager in the voluntary sector, a learning mentor, and in church planting. At home I enjoy DIY and cooking.
Picture of Patrick Davidson
I’m Patrick and I oversee one of the small groups at Windsor. I work in a sixth form centre, and volunteer with CAP and The Dock café. Prior to this I worked as a project manager in the voluntary sector, a learning mentor, and in church planting. At home I enjoy DIY and cooking.