Following a break for Advent and Christmas, today David returned to our studies in 1 Samuel, looking at chapter 15. He took us to what he considers the second best-known phrase in the book of 1 Samuel (for the No.1 phrase, see next week’s Deep Dive!):
“TO OBEY IS BETTER THAN SACRIFICE…”
1 Samuel 15:22
- Why is obedience better than sacrifice?
The important principle stated by the prophet Samuel here is that obedience to God reflects a heart totally committed to God. Religious rituals, acts and practices alone are not sufficient if not accompanied by genuine obedience and alignment to God’s ways and God’s word. - What is the background to these words?
Saul had been told by God through Samuel to destroy ALL the Amalekites and their belongings. This was God’s judgement for their 400-year untold cruelty to Israel. Saul mobilised his army of 210,000 soldiers and launched an attack, but he decided to spare the king of the Amalekites, Agag, and also some of the best animals. The next morning, Samuel confronted Saul about his disobedience:
“WHAT IS MORE PLEASING TO THE LORD: YOUR BURNT OFFERINGS AND SACRIFICES OR YOUR OBEDIENCE TO HIS VOICE? LISTEN! OBEDIENCE IS BETTER THAN SACRIFICE, AND SUBMISSION IS BETTER THAN OFFERING THE FAT OF RAMS.”
1 Samuel 15:22 (New Living Translation)
- What is the outcome?
We read these solemn words:
THEN SAUL SAID TO SAMUEL, “I HAVE SINNED. I VIOLATED THE LORD’S COMMAND AND YOUR INSTRUCTIONS…NOW I BEG YOU, FORGIVE MY SIN AND COME BACK WITH ME, SO THAT I MAY WORSHIP THE LORD.” BUT SAMUEL SAID TO HIM, “I WILL NOT GO BACK WITH YOU. YOU HAVE REJECTED THE WORD OF THE LORD, AND THE LORD HAS REJECTED YOU AS KING OVER ISRAEL!”
1 Samuel 15:24-26
After this event, Samuel never met with King Saul again. God’s voice (through his prophet Samuel) in Saul’s life has gone. Saul’s life begins to unravel in preparation for a new king.
- What can we learn from this tragic story?
Despite appearing to repent, Saul made 3 excuses for his disobedience:
- He emphasised what he did right and downplayed what he did wrong:
“BUT I DID OBEY THE LORD,” SAUL SAID. “I WENT ON THE MISSION THE LORD ASSIGNED ME. I COMPLETELY DESTROYED THE AMALEKITES AND BROUGHT BACK AGAG THEIR KING.”
1 Samuel 15:20
2. He pointed the finger at other people:
“I WAS AFRAID OF THE MEN AND SO I GAVE IN TO THEM.”
1 Samuel 15:24
3. He tried to rationalise/spiritualise his behaviour:
“THE SOLDIERS TOOK SHEEP AND CATTLE FROM THE PLUNDER, THE BEST OF WHAT WAS DEVOTED TO GOD, IN ORDER TO SACRIFICE THEM TO THE LORD YOUR GOD AT GILGAL.”
1 Samuel 15:21
As David said, it is easy for us to use any or all of Saul’s excuses whenever we fail to obey God. Partial obedience is a contradiction in terms. Full obedience is evidence of our love for God.
WE KNOW THAT WE HAVE COME TO KNOW HIM IF WE KEEP HIS COMMANDS. WHOEVER SAYS, “I KNOW HIM,” BUT DOES NOT DO WHAT HE COMMANDS IS A LIAR, AND THE TRUTH IS NOT IN THAT PERSON. BUT IF ANYONE OBEYS HIS WORD, LOVE FOR GOD IS TRULY MADE COMPLETE IN THEM.
1 John 2:3-5
New Year Resolution for 2026:
- To pursue obedience to God in all of my life.